| AT | Name | Year | Hall of Presidents |
|---|---|---|---|
| - | - | 1888-1890 | |
| 5 | Harry Allen Reese | 1890-1891 | |
| 6 | James Boyd McDonnald | 1891 | |
| 12 | Hugh La Maskes | 1891 | |
| 17 | Charles DeLong Chandler | 1892 | |
| 22 | George Henry Whaley | 1892-1893 | |
| 15 | Jesse Bradford Becher | 1893-1894 | |
| 20 | Burt Elihu Forbes | 1894-1895 | |
| 30 | Ernest Gapson Ames | 1895-1896 | |
| 34 | Lowe Arnott Ricketts | 1896-1897 | |
| 46 | Chas Heudy Jr. | 1897-1897 | |
| 61 | Carl Beghtol | 1898-1899 | |
| - | - | 1899-1900 | |
| 53 | Lloyd Hamington McKiller | 1900-1901 | |
| 77 | James Dfays Bell | 1901-1902 | |
| - | - | 1902-1903 | |
| 84 | Orrington Thomas Hawkes Swan | 1903-1904 | |
| 112 | Edwin Harrison Brown | 1905-1906 | |
| 109 | Nate Downes | 1906-1907 | |
| 125 | Paul Thomas Bell | 1907-1908 | |
| 131 | James Lee Wilson | 1908-1909 | |
| 153 | Stanley McCook Huffman | 1909-1910 | |
| 155 | Maxwell Vance Bequhol | 1910-1911 | |
| 175 | James Arthur Whevey | 1911-1912 | |
| 173 | Hugh John Birmingham | 1912-1913 | |
| 176 | Edward Emmett Murphy Jr. | 1913-1914 | |
| 194 | Thomas Germain Egan | 1915-1916 | |
| 235 | Debs Loveland Anderson | 1916-1917 | |
| 253 | Loyal E. Shannon | 1918-1919 | |
| 260 | Norwell Euguine Dirhl | 1919-1920 | |
| 268 | Richard Lee Triplett | 1920-1921 | |
| 296 | Frank W. Wingon | 1921-1922 | |
| 300 | Ward Menard Randol | 1922 | |
| 319 | Byron Elleott Ames | 1923-1924 | |
| 308 | John C. Whithood | 1924-1926 | |
| 351 | Fred Funnell Vette | 1926-1927 | |
| 371 | Richard Frank Vette | 1927-1928 | |
| 399 | Bruce Henry Thomas | 1928-1929 | |
| 381 | Charles Wade Abbott | 1929-1930 | |
| 412 | Allen Belmer Beaumont | 1930-1931 | |
| 435 | Edgar Street Wescott | 1931-1932 | Pictured |
| 404 | Lewis Richards Ricketts | 1932-1933 | Pictured |
| 454 | Byron William Gouldwig | 1933-1934 | |
| 464 | Harry Lewis Rudolph | 1934-1935 | Pictured |
| - | - | 1935-1936 | |
| 504 | William Wilson Marsh | 1936-1937 | |
| 502 | Winfield Todd Elias | 1937-1938 | Pictured |
| - | - | 1938-1939 | |
| 583 | Robert Dulley Pillsbury | 1939-1940 | Pictured |
| 573 | John Luke Weingarton | 1940-1941 | Pictured |
| 581 | John Stewart Jr. | 1941-1942 | Pictured |
| 625 | Richard W. Peters | 1942-1943 | Pictured |
| 650 | John C. Anderson | 1943-1944 | Pictured |
| 664 | Thomas W. Hyland | 1943-1944 | Pictured |
| 696 | Eugene S. Merchant | 1944-1946 | Pictured |
| 659 | Justin L. Berger | 1946-1947 | Pictured |
| - | Frank J. Mattoon | 1947-1948 | Pictured |
| 758 | Douglas E. Peters Jr. | 1948-1949 | Pictured |
| 774 | William C. Bock | 1949-1950 | Pictured |
| 801 | Keith O. Lytle | 1950-1951 | Pictured |
| 788 | William H. Hein Jr. | 1951-1952 | Pictured |
| 825 | Keith G. Mumby | 1952-1953 | Pictured |
| 850 | Theodore W. Barger | 1953-1954 | Pictured |
| 866 | Jack W. Gillespie | 1954-1955 | Pictured |
| 888 | Charles L. Smith Jr. | 1955-1956 | Pictured |
| 901 | Richard M. Reische | 1956-1957 | Pictured |
| 951 | James D. Jacques | 1957-1958 | Pictured |
| 938 | John P. Glynn | 1958-1959 | Pictured |
| 956 | Lawrence C. Romjue | 1959-1960 | Pictured |
| 989 | John C. Craft | 1960-1961 | Pictured |
| 1019 | John Roger Myers | 1961-1962 | Pictured |
| 1020 | Ralph James Goodell | 1962-1963 | Pictured |
| 1037 | John E. Lahiff | 1963-1964 | Pictured |
| 1058 | John H. Lonnquist Jr. | 1964-1965 | Pictured |
| 1092 | Lawrence A. Frolick | 1965-1966 | Pictured |
| 1113 | Larry D. Johnson | 1966-1967 | Pictured |
| 1134 | James N. Shreck | 1967-1968 | Pictured |
| 1160 | Thomas G. Morgan | 1968-1969 | Pictured |
| 1193 | David R. Buntain | 1969-1970 | Pictured |
| 1257 | David K. Karnes | 1970-1971 | Pictured |
| 1265 | Kerry Winterer | 1971-1972 | Pictured |
| 1328 | Paul C. Jessen | 1972-1973 | Pictured |
| 1352 | Stephen M. Kalhorn | 1973-1974 | Pictured |
| 1389 | Michael J. McGahan | 1974-1975 | Pictured |
| 1403 | Charles Heider | 1975-1976 | Pictured |
| 1442 | Bryan J. Tuma | 1976-1977 | Pictured |
| 1472 | Gregory Elliott | 1977-1978 | Pictured |
| 1476 | Russ Peterson | 1978-1979 | Pictured |
| 1516 | Greg Bentz | 1979-1980 | Pictured |
| 1542 | Kirk J. Trofholz | 1980-1981 | Pictured |
| 1559 | Andrew Bock | 1981-1982 | Pictured |
| 1596 | David Nikunen | 1982-1983 | Pictured |
| 1608 | John Dittman | 1983-1984 | Pictured |
| 1633 | T.J. Kinnick | 1984-1985 | Pictured |
| 1663 | Mark Leeper | 1985-1986 | Pictured |
| 1685 | John Ward | 1986-1987 | Pictured |
| 1708 | Stephen Thomas | 1987-1988 | Pictured |
| 1730 | Daniel Dolan | 1988-1989 | Pictured |
| 1764 | Chad Packhurst | 1989-1990 | Pictured |
| 1778 | John J. Reefe III | 1990-1991 | Pictured |
| 1801 | Thomas Callahan | 1991-1992 | Pictured |
| 1838 | Timothy Dolan | 1992-1993 | Pictured |
| 1871 | Ryan Jochim | 1993-1994 | |
| 1874 | Patrick Reefe | 1994-1995 | |
| 1888 | Brad Kratky | 1995-1996 | Pictured |
| 1903 | Joseph Thibodeau | 1996-1997 | Pictured |
| 1938 | Andrew Scott Mattox | 1997-1999 | Pictured |
| 1953 | Ryan E. Hartung | 1999-2000 | Pictured |
| 2004 | Mark D.Kratina Jr. | 2000-2001 | Pictured |
| 1986 | Todd Jeffrey Mattox | 2001-2002 | Pictured |
| 2016 | Kyle Robert Johnson | 2002-2003 | Pictured |
| 2038 | Anthony Michael Hohn | 2003-2004 | Pictured |
| 2051 | Brian Richard Butler | 2004-2005 | Pictured |
| 2077 | Greg Walklin | 2005-2006 | Pictured |
| 2096 | Russell Swan | 2006-2007 | Pictured |
| 2116 | Scott Hackman | 2007-2008 | Pictured |
| 2136 | Kenton Moore | 2008-2009 | Pictured |
| 2163 | Scott Barker | 2009-2010 | Pictured |
| 2183 | Dave Frayser | 2010-2011 | Pictured |
| 2225 | Andrew Dowd | 2011-2012 | Pictured |
| 2229 | Micheal Mumaugh | 2012-2013 | Pictured |
| 2259 | Kurt Siebert | 2013-2014 | Pictured |
| 2288 | Michael Nordell | 2014-2015 | Pictured |
| 2318 | Alex Kindopp | 2015-2016 | Pictured |
| 2386 | Stephen Enke | 2016-2017 | Pictured |
| 2380 | Samuel Brower | 2017-2018 | Pictured |
| 2399 | John Pfeifer | 2018-2019 | Pictured |
| 2451 | Kevin Woolworth | 2019-2020 | Pictured |
| 2472 | Erik Goodwin | 2020-2021 | Pictured |
| 2527 | Dominic Pfeifer | 2021-2022 | Pictured |
| 2554 | Kyle Auman | 2022-2023 | Pictured |
| 2563 | Grant Auman | 2023-2024 | |
| 2587 | Charlie Lorkovic | 2024-2025 | |
| 2613 | Nathan Siy | 2025-2026 |